MPR-paper issueshttps://git.ufz.de/ottor/MPR-paper/-/issues2021-12-08T10:38:34+01:00https://git.ufz.de/ottor/MPR-paper/-/issues/8remove copyright statement2021-12-08T10:38:34+01:00Robert Schwepperemove copyright statementRobert SchweppeRobert Schweppehttps://git.ufz.de/ottor/MPR-paper/-/issues/7update of manuscript - round 22021-11-23T14:29:19+01:00Robert Schweppeupdate of manuscript - round 2This updates the manuscript in order to address to [editor's comments](https://editor.copernicus.org/GMD/ms_records/gmd-2021-103) from 12 Nov 2021:
>>>
Dear authors,
The responses you provided address well most reviewers' comments.
One ...This updates the manuscript in order to address to [editor's comments](https://editor.copernicus.org/GMD/ms_records/gmd-2021-103) from 12 Nov 2021:
>>>
Dear authors,
The responses you provided address well most reviewers' comments.
One common comment from the three reviewers is the detailed technical descriptions of the MPR tool that may not be interested to all readers, and the lack of hypotheses or research questions in the manuscript. The answers you provided are correct, GMD model description papers have the objective to provide detailed technical descriptions of models that are in general very difficult to publish in other scientific journals.
However, I do feel that there is a mix of content in this manuscript that is of interest of two separate audiences, a more generalist hydrology-modelling community, and a more specialized scientific programming audience. It is not necessarily clear what parts of the manuscript are of interest to one audience or the other. Also, the manuscript does not clearly state the goal.
To remedy this issue, I propose a simple fix. In the last paragraph of the introduction, you can add a few sentences describing the overall objective of the manuscript and a road map for different audiences. For example, something like: "The overall goal of this manuscript is to .... It can be of interest to 'audience 1' and 'audience 2'". Then continue with text starting in Line 89. Afterwards, provide the road map: "Readers interested in [audience 1] can read sections x, y, z without loss of general understanding. For those interested in implementation details we recommend especial attention to sections a, b, c."
Of course you can phrase this in a different way, but the important point is that you provide the overall aim of the manuscript with the target audiences, and a road map for these different audiences.
Best regards,
Carlos Sierra
>>>Robert SchweppeRobert Schweppehttps://git.ufz.de/ottor/MPR-paper/-/issues/6Figures for paper2021-09-28T13:20:51+02:00Robert SchweppeFigures for paper- order of final figure is chronologically not good (should be same as Rohinis figure)
- show a region with a high contrast (Missouri, Ohio)
- add another level1 aggregation for HUC2 and ICON (R02B04)
- reference for paper: inner rings ...- order of final figure is chronologically not good (should be same as Rohinis figure)
- show a region with a high contrast (Missouri, Ohio)
- add another level1 aggregation for HUC2 and ICON (R02B04)
- reference for paper: inner rings or MultiPolygons are not supported
- 1st figure in the tradition of Rohini (namelist goes in appendix)
- 2nd figure example namelist and interdependency
- 3rd figure broadcasting etc.
- 4th figure: Noah-MP
- 5th figure: EU-SoilHydroGridshttps://git.ufz.de/ottor/MPR-paper/-/issues/5create a figure showing the remapping capabilities of MPR2021-09-28T13:20:44+02:00Robert Schweppecreate a figure showing the remapping capabilities of MPRThere needs to be a figure demonstrating MPR can handle various remappings. There needs to be a figure showing the remapping of a rectangular grid (e.g. SOILGRIDS 250m regular latlon grid) to a) to polygon-based shapes (e.g. HUC6 on CONU...There needs to be a figure demonstrating MPR can handle various remappings. There needs to be a figure showing the remapping of a rectangular grid (e.g. SOILGRIDS 250m regular latlon grid) to a) to polygon-based shapes (e.g. HUC6 on CONUS) and b) an hat of ICON (e.g. R02B05 grid for CONUS).Robert SchweppeRobert Schweppehttps://git.ufz.de/ottor/MPR-paper/-/issues/4make MPR code ready for version 1.02021-09-28T13:20:39+02:00Robert Schweppemake MPR code ready for version 1.0- add documentation
- establish pytest
- clean up code and test examples
- make project public- add documentation
- establish pytest
- clean up code and test examples
- make project publicRobert SchweppeRobert Schweppehttps://git.ufz.de/ottor/MPR-paper/-/issues/2Application of MPR - mHM test basin2021-09-28T13:20:32+02:00Robert SchweppeApplication of MPR - mHM test basin- include MPR in existing code base of mHM
- modify transfer functions for ksat (use TFs applied in #1) and show their effect on streamflow in mHM test basin1- include MPR in existing code base of mHM
- modify transfer functions for ksat (use TFs applied in #1) and show their effect on streamflow in mHM test basin1Conduct experimentsRobert SchweppeRobert Schweppe2019-02-11https://git.ufz.de/ottor/MPR-paper/-/issues/1Validation of MPR with existing soil data bases2021-09-28T13:20:21+02:00Robert SchweppeValidation of MPR with existing soil data bases- scan for existing sources
- check for availability of source data, transfer functions and results
- e.g. soil database HYPRES, Polaris
- check if soilgrids has derived effective soil hydraulic parameters
- focus on key parameters ksat,...- scan for existing sources
- check for availability of source data, transfer functions and results
- e.g. soil database HYPRES, Polaris
- check if soilgrids has derived effective soil hydraulic parameters
- focus on key parameters ksat, fc, porosity
- run MPR and reproduce the resultsConduct experimentsRobert SchweppeRobert Schweppe2019-02-28https://git.ufz.de/ottor/MPR-paper/-/issues/31) Application of MPR - Noah-MP2019-02-11T10:24:05+01:00Robert Schweppe1) Application of MPR - Noah-MP- add MPR to model_wrapper
- create Cosby and MvG Ksat values with MPR (TF from review most cited, e.g. Vereecken 1992)
- modify soil parameters and use them in Noah-MP version that can read 3D parameter fields
- CONUS-wide simulations (...- add MPR to model_wrapper
- create Cosby and MvG Ksat values with MPR (TF from review most cited, e.g. Vereecken 1992)
- modify soil parameters and use them in Noah-MP version that can read 3D parameter fields
- CONUS-wide simulations (if applicable, highlight hotspots, where variability is higher)
- compare long term runoff or ETConduct experimentsRobert SchweppeRobert Schweppe2019-02-04